Clean and Elegant

Clean and Elegant

Monday, 5 October 2015

Where is Emma Fillipoff (Four)


 



previous segments of Where is Emma Fillipoff

Four: Mental illness runs in the family.

"Mental illness runs in the family." Shelley whispers this sentence to the camera in one of the earliest t.v. clips after Emma’s disappearance. The most prevalent theories of what happened to Emma involve some sort of mental breakdown or psychotic break. Leading up to her disappearance, Emma showed signs of paranoia and depression. Is this why she’d chosen to stay at the women’s shelter? A former roommate reported that one time in the middle of the night, she’d woken to find Emma outside, totally out of it and tripping out on the grass, and the stars. The friend had informed Emma’s father James about this odd behaviour. Although James had offered to pay for a plane ticket home,  Emma insisted that she was fine and could take care of herself. Intensely private, Emma had been mortified to learn that her friend had called her father. Shelley never heard about the incident until much later. Had she known, she says she would have flown out.
After significant probing from Shelley, staff at the Sandi Merriman House admitted that Emma often acted very paranoid. They said that Emma went through a period of selling all her stuff. Following this, she began to throw things away. She would carry both her own stuff and objects from the shelter first to the lawn, and then to the curb. A lamp, a fan, a chair. When staff made her bring the objects back, Emma would protest. “It’s making too much noise,” she’d say. “It’s saying things to me.” As soon as the items were back inside, Emma would try to get rid of them again. The second time she would haul them across the street to the courthouse.  
Video surveillance footage from the 7-11 and the YMCA reveal that Emma often seemed afraid to go outside. And on the day of her disappearance, a witness saw Emma standing at a crosswalk, but refusing to cross. For years, Emma had been a manic walker. She almost always walked barefoot, clutching her shoes in her hands, refusing to put them on. Her feet would become bloody from walking so far. Thin and conveniently vegan, people hardly ever saw Emma eat. Shelley thinks she developed an eating disorder. Whether this was the cause or result of her mental distress, we don’t know. Shelter staff also reported that Emma used to overhydrate, consuming gallons and gallons of water at a time. This is common for people who undereat. Rarely, overhydration depletes your body’s electrolytes and causes something called water intoxication. The condition can be fatal. Interestingly enough, symptoms of overhydration mimic psychotic tendencies, including “inappropriate behaviour, delusions, hallucinations, confusion, and disorientation” (Source: Farrell and Bower, PMC). And yet, it is impossible to conclude that overhydrating led to Emma’s psychological deterioration. Quite often the symptom appears as part of a mosaic of unusual and compulsive behaviour.
A year before she was last seen, Emma had returned home to Perth, Ontario. A congenital knee condition had been giving her back problems and she was looking into treatment. In retrospect, Shelley realizes that during that time, Emma was acting “way too happy… it didn’t look drug induced… it looked like she was avoiding life, wandering around Perth all day and all night.” She stayed with friends and with her father, often cooking for him though rarely eating herself. Whenever she ran into her mom, she’d say she was on her way somewhere.
“Can’t stay,” she’d say. And off she’d go, fanatically walking. With her mother, Emma maintained a certain distance. Perhaps she was afraid that Shelley would see through the happy, flighty façade. Her father James didn’t ask as many questions. Like Emma, he is non-confrontational and secretive. Though he worried that Emma never ate, he felt she deserved her privacy. Very seldom would he ever bring up his concerns with Shelley. When Emma was in her early twenties, James divorced Shelley for a younger woman. The divorce was pretty brutal and Shelley is quite open to the fact that around that time she suffered from a full-blown mental health crisis. For three years, she had to quit teaching and go on disability. She describes lying on the bathroom floor all day, trying to will herself up in time for when her youngest child got home from school. Emma had been around for part of the separation and witnessed some events that must surely have traumatized her.
Shelley: “I really lost it Erica, not only did I have a breakdown but I went after James. I did a lot of things that really really disturbed Emma and I didn’t have a chance to give her my side. To tell her I was sick. That it wasn’t her mother acting in that manner… Something had really happened to me. I never had the chance to explain it to her. So she witnessed quite a violent attack on James one night at his house and she had to call the police and have me removed… Emma couldn’t handle that. Someone who was non-confrontational, even verbally. To see me going bezerk. I mean I was bezerk, I had a knife in my hand. I was really gone. I wasn’t going to hurt him.”
Emma: “My parents’ marriage in shambles.
My father turning to me.
My mother hating us both.
And me. Always the good listener.
Too nice to say that it hurt me too."

Shelley and Emma never ended up talking about what happened. Soon afterwards, Emma moved to Victoria, limiting her contact with her mother to cryptic flowery emails and vague elusive phone calls.
 
Shelley and James are on much better terms now. They often have family dinners together with their other children. Emma’s absence is blatant and painful, but seldom mentioned.  
 
“No one will tell me what they think,” says Shelley. “Because I know what I know.”  Throughout the case, the rest of Emma’s family has kept a low profile. Behind Emma’s posters, Shelley is really the face of the search, though both Emma’s father and youngest brother agreed to interviews with the Fifth Estate. Ultimately, the Fifth Estate did not include the younger brother’s interview in the documentary, but this was the CBC’s choice. Apart from Shelley and Emma’s youngest brother, the family refused to watch the program. Perhaps it is too heartbreaking. Especially if they allow themselves to consider at all the fact that they advised Shelley not to go get Emma. Shelley had always been the disciplinarian parent and they didn’t think Emma would be able to cope with this. In any case, everyone had Emma’s best interest at heart. Nobody intended for things to come to this.
 
“I wish Emma were here to see how well you get along,” Emma’s older sister said to her parents one night at a family dinner. “How everything turned out just fine.” Except Shelley’s not really fine and Emma’s not there.
End of Part Four.
-Written by Erica J. Schmidt

Where is Emma Fillipoff
Read More:
 


HAVE YOU SEEN EMMA?
Please Share Your Stories and Tips
Help Find Emma Fillipoff Facebook Group
Email Erica: ericaschmidt85(at)gmail(dot)com
(contact form below)
Email Shelley: fillipoff(at)hotmail(dot)com
Call the police.



Exuberant Bodhisattva on Facebook
Erica on Twitter: @mypelvicfloor




Where is Emma Fillipoff (Three)

previous segments of Where is Emma Fillipoff
ONE: The Grieving Mothers of Perth, Ontario
Three: Wednesday, November 28, 2012

The day she went missing, Emma’s actions indicated that perhaps she was planning for something. Police say that on the morning of her disappearance, Emma had spoken to staff at the Chateau Victoria Hotel. There she had parked her van which contained almost all of her possessions, including her passport, laptop, journals and camera.

At 8:23 a.m., she purchased a $200 pre-paid credit card at a 7-11. Security footage shows Emma hesitating before she leaves the store. She keeps opening and closing the door. She alternates between frantically, anxiously looking outside, and pacing and waiting in the 7-11.



Emma paces in and out of the YMCA, about a week before her disappearance.
Footage of her in the 7-11 is included in the Fifth Estate documentary, "Finding Emma."

“I feel like I’m being stalked,” her journals say.
Even earlier that day, Emma had called Shelley. “Don’t come, not today Mom, not today,” she'd told her, the same words she’d repeated so many times over the past five days.  Shelley says that the call came around 7:30 a.m., Eastern Time. In Victoria, it would have been 4:30 in the morning. Had Emma slept at all the night? Without telling Emma, Shelley made arrangements to fly out and get her.

Some people think that on November 28, Emma visited the library around noon. She used to sit and read in the children’s section. Emma seemed to be the kind of girl who could fit in almost anywhere. But did she feel like she belonged in any of these places?

Emma:
"I chased death all my life. Because I was dead.
Sleeping was escape from all the pain.
And stories were the sweet music rain.
I love my mom.
But I could not cause her pain."
 
For the last nine months before she disappeared, Emma lived on and off at Sandi Merriman House, a women’s shelter. Nobody really knows why. Shelley had only found out she’d been staying there a few days before Emma vanished. The emails she’d been sending her friends and mother had been vague, bubbly and poetic. “Life is love.” “Everything is perfect and beautiful.” That sort of thing.
Sandi Merriman staff say that they saw Emma leave the shelter at about 6 p.m. Minutes earlier, at 5:54 p.m., Emma had purchased a pre-paid cell phone at the same 7-11 where she’d bought the pre-paid credit card that morning. It is curious that she would buy a cellphone now, since she’d never owned or wanted one before. The phone was never activated. Just like when Emma bought the credit card, she seemed afraid to exit the store, peering out the door as though looking for someone she didn’t want to see.
At 6:10 p.m. she got in a cab near the shelter and asked to go to the airport. The cab driver told her it would be 60 bucks. Emma had two to three thousand dollars in her bank account, but she told the driver she couldn’t afford the fare. The cab driver said she’d been acting weird. She insisted that he drop her off exactly where he’d found her. Before getting out, she asked him if she could sit in his car for awhile. She clearly didn’t want to leave. We don’t know if there was actually someone out there or if it was just in her mind. The cab driver had his radio on. Emma stared at it. Visibly frightened, she asked, “what’s that noise? Why is there noise coming out of that?” She paid for the ride with her bank card, and left.

Emma, with the long braids she used to wear
Between 7 and 8 p.m., a friend of Emma's ran into her near the Empress Hotel which is somewhat close to the water. Barefoot and clutching her shoes, Emma seemed anxious, disoriented and out of it. Her friend called 9-1-1. Police claim that they questioned her extensively, and felt that she was not a harm to herself or others.
According to the police officer who was interviewed on the Fifth Estate documentary, Emma told them, “I’m just working through some things right now. I’m going for a walk and then I’m going to a friend’s house.”  It’s not an enormous surprise that up until the last moment anyone saw her, Emma wouldn’t let on to how much she was suffering. Still, Shelley feels adamant that the police did not do due diligence in letting someone as vulnerable as Emma walk off into the night. It would have been so easy for them to accompany her to her friend’s house, or wherever she was going. Instead they simply let her go.
Three hours after Emma was last seen, Shelley arrived at Sandy Merriman House, only to discover that Emma had not claimed her bed. Immediately, Shelley contacted the police. They declared Emma a missing person, but Shelley maintains that they did nothing for three or four days. “They told me she was out partying,” Shelley said. Shelley insisted that her daughter was not a partier. Familiar with addicts of all kinds, the women’s shelter staff confirmed Shelley’s belief, reporting that Emma showed no signs of drug use.
There were errors on the police’s initial press release regarding Emma’s disappearance. The press release stated that Emma was last seen at a different corner and that she was with friends. When Shelley inquired about it, the person at the office claimed it was a typo. “Why don’t you focus on looking for your daughter?” she’d told Shelley.
End of Part Three.
-Written by Erica J. Schmidt

Source: The Fifth Estate (CBC)
Clues That May Help in the Search for Emma Fillipoff

Where is Emma Fillipoff
Read More:
ONE: The Grieving Mothers of Perth, Ontario
TWO: She's Missing
 
 

HAVE YOU SEEN EMMA?
Please Share Your Stories and Tips
Help Find Emma Fillipoff Facebook Group
Email Erica: ericaschmidt85(at)gmail(dot)com
(contact form below)
Email Shelley: fillipoff(at)hotmail(dot)com
Call the police.



Exuberant Bodhisattva on Facebook
Erica on Twitter: @mypelvicfloor
 
 
 
 
 
 



Where is Emma Fillipoff (Two)

previous segments of Where is Emma Fillipoff
ONE: The Grieving Mothers of Perth, Ontario
 
 
 
 


Two: She’s Missing

So many things run through my mind every minute of every day. Emma’s life essence courses through my veins so I can feel her being within my own. So many fears haunt me. There will never be a moment’s peace until my beautiful, amazing daughter is found. She is everywhere I look and yet nowhere to be found.” (Shelley, Facebook Status, May 2015)
 
Shelley and I sit on the couch where Shelley spends most of her days. The couch is covered in dog hair.
 
“You can only imagine how little I care about keeping the house clean,” Shelley says. Cash, her bulldog lies between us and snores loudly. Shelley curls herself into a corner and starts smoking, an old habit she took up again, after more than thirty years. Throughout the interview, she smokes rather vigorously and barely ever smiles.
 
Shelley was my fantastic grade six French teacher. Grade six was wonderful year. Unlike so many French teachers, Shelley taught with enthusiasm, humour and creativity. I remember her being so vibrant and beautiful. She is still beautiful, but there’s a weariness in her face and in her eyes. She looks very tired and very sad. Her voice is so soft that sometimes it’s hard to hear her above the sound of the dog snoring.
 

Shelley

I asked Shelley what Emma was like growing up. Artistic and free-spirited, Emma was the quiet girl who was everywhere. She was always welcome in any group. Although she wouldn’t say much, she laughed a lot and her smile was magnetic. Everyone loved being around Emma. From the outside, Emma appeared to love her life which was filled with piles of friends, dance classes, photography and writing. And yet, when Shelley read Emma’s old journals, she discovered that her daughter had been unwell and unhappy from as young as eleven years old
 

But she made sure that nobody ever saw that side of her,” said Shelley. Shelley has since asked friends and parents of friends if they ever got sense of how much Emma was suffering. Nobody had any idea. 

 

In addition to being secretive, Shelley describes Emma as “non-confrontational.” While her siblings would debate and stand up to Shelley’s rules, Emma would simply retreat into her room.

“Emma wanted to grow up from the time she was about eight,” said Shelley. In objection to her curfew, Emma moved out on her sixteenth birthday. But she left a note telling her family she’d gone to her friend Ellen’s house.  She didn’t just disappear. 


Emma with Ellen's sister, Marie.
Both Ellen and Marie Flanagan did interviews for the Fifth Estate documentary, "Finding Emma."

After discovering that Ellen’s mom also enforced a curfew, Emma decided to rent an apartment with an older guy.  Although this roommate wasn’t her boyfriend, Emma had already begun to attract men far older than her. Physically stunning and quietly mature, by the time she was sixteen, she had a boyfriend who was 26. A bit of stretch, but not surprising given Emma’s beauty and grown-up persona.  To make rent, Emma, quit school and worked at KC’s video, a gem of a dive all us Perthites know well.
 


Emma, always so beautiful

It was at this time that Shelley realized that she couldn’t take a hard line with Emma like she could with her other children. At any sort of conflict, Emma would withdraw. In attempts to keep her daughter as close as possible, Shelley gave in to Emma’s request to see her younger brother. He was only eight and heartbroken that Emma was gone. The two adored each other. Emma has three siblings and Shelley claims she was close to all of them.
 
On Sundays, Shelley would drop her youngest son at KC’s video so that he and Emma could hang out and watch movies together.  At the same time, Shelley would drop off shampoo, treats and fresh fruit. Things she knew Emma would be struggling to afford.
 
Emma lived on her own for eight months. Finally, in September, she asked to come home. Like many teenagers, Emma detested high school. Instead of enduring the torture, she enrolled at the alternative school, where she could work independently. Her marks were excellent and she won a scholarship to Loyalist College in Belleville. She studied photojournalism, combining her talent for writing and taking pictures.
 
I wonder how Emma would frame her own story.

When I was in India, I watched the CBC Fifth Estate documentary on Emma’s disappearance. “Finding Emma,” it is called. Alone on my bed, I remember staring at the screen and feeling terrified and haunted. As an actress read words from Emma’s journals, I got the sense that I wasn’t supposed to be hearing them.
 
“What was in her journals was horrifying,” said Shelley. “So I don’t know if she was psychotic, or schizophrenic, or major depression issues. I don’t know.” The police don’t know either. Nobody knows.

Emma: "There is promise of flight.
And I lay in fear
In fear somehow
Somewhere
Sometime
Fear crept in.
She’s missing.
I am missing."

End of Part Two.
-Written by Erica J. Schmidt
 
Where is Emma Filllipoff
 
Read More:
 
 
(NEXT SEGMENT) THREE: Wednesday, November 28, 2012

FOUR: Mental illness runs in the family
FIVE: A Mother's Instinct
SIX: Okay. So I'm dead.
SEVEN: She ran away because she fucking hates her parents.
EIGHT: Safe Until She Returns
NINE: A Perfect, Beautiful Family


HAVE YOU SEEN EMMA?
Please Share Your Stories and Tips
Help Find Emma Fillipoff Facebook Group
Email Erica: ericaschmidt85(at)gmail(dot)com
(contact form below)
Email Shelley: fillipoff(at)hotmail(dot)com
Call the police.



Exuberant Bodhisattva on Facebook
Erica on Twitter: @mypelvicfloor



 


Where is Emma Fillipoff (One)

Where is Emma Fillipoff
One: The Grieving Mothers of Perth Ontario

 
On November 23, 2012, Shelley Fillipoff heard her phone ring around midnight. Immediately, she got the feeling that something was very wrong with one of her children. It was Emma, her 26-year-old daughter calling from Victoria, British Columbia. Emma was in tears and highly distressed.
“Mom, I want to come home,” she said. She wanted Shelley to fly out and get her.
 
“Of course,” Shelley said. She promised to book her flight as soon as they got off the phone.
 
“Are you booking your flight?” Emma asked. She seemed incredibly concerned. Once again, Shelley promised that she would as soon as she hung up.

“Right away, honey,” she promised. They hung up, and without wasting any time, Shelley booked her flight and packed to go get her daughter. Within a few hours, Emma called back.

“No, Mom, don’t come,” she said. “Not today.” She told Shelley that she wanted to figure things out for herself. Respecting her daughter’s request for privacy, Shelley cancelled her flight. This went on for four more days. An anguished Emma calling, begging her mom to come get her. Shelley booking her flight, packing her suitcase. And then Emma calls back, her mind changed. “No, Mom, don’t come. Not today.”
 
"Don't come. Not today, Mom, not today." These were the last words Shelley would ever hear her daughter speak. Emma called early on the morning of Wednesday, November 28.
 
At this point, Shelley could no longer ignore her instinct that something was terribly amiss. Her ex-husband and children urged her to heed Emma’s vacillating wishes, but Shelley got on a plane and flew across the country to bring her daughter home. She was still in the plane at 8 P.M. the last time Emma was seen. Shelley arrived at 11. By then, Emma had already vanished into the night. No one has any idea where she went.

“The days are unbearably long and yet it’s almost been three years.” Unbearably long, unimaginably horrible. This is how Shelley Fillipoff describes her life.
 
I met Shelley this July in her family home just outside of Lanark, a tiny village about ten kilometres from my hometown of Perth Ontario. Although Perth has been voted, “the prettiest town in Ontario,” I’ve always felt haunted by the community’s disturbing amount of tragedy. As I grew up, there seemed to be a disproportionate amount of pre-mature death and disturbing events. Fires, drugs, a double-murder suicide, a vice grip attack in a restaurant broom closet, a child pornography arrest, inordinate levels of cancer and countless young people who die suddenly of illness, accidents or suicide. Perhaps it’s just my morbid fixation on death, or maybe it’s because the community is so small. But whatever the reason, Perth has its share of grieving mothers.  The day Emma disappeared, Shelley became one of them.
 
End of Part One

-Written by Erica J. Schmidt

Where is Emma Fillipoff

HAVE YOU SEEN EMMA?
Please Share Your Stories and Tips
Help Find Emma Fillipoff Facebook Group
Email Erica: ericaschmidt85(at)gmail(dot)com
(contact form below)
Email Shelley: fillipoff(at)hotmail(dot)com
Call the police.



Exuberant Bodhisattva on Facebook
Erica on Twitter: @mypelvicfloor